A toddler’s autism diagnosis often brings a flood of questions. Should we start services right away? How much is enough? Does it make a difference?
A well-known 2009 study in Pediatrics is one of the first randomized trials to look at these questions in children as young as 18 months. Here is what it found, in plain language, and what it does not tell us.
Note: We read the full text of the open-access version of this paper, including the abstract, methods, results and discussion.
What the study looked at
Researchers at the University of Washington tested the Early Start Denver Model (ESDM). ESDM is a comprehensive early intervention that uses teaching strategies from applied behavior analysis (ABA). Therapists deliver it within warm, play-based, relationship-focused routines. Parents are trained to use the same strategies in everyday life.
The design was a randomized, controlled trial:
- 48 children diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder between 18 and 30 months of age.
- Children were randomly assigned to one of two groups.
- The ESDM group was offered about 20 hours per week of therapist-delivered intervention, plus parent training and at least 5 hours per week of parent-delivered strategies, for 2 years.
- The comparison group received assessments and recommendations, and was referred to the services commonly available in their community.
Examiners who tested the children did not know which group each child was in. Children were assessed at the start, after 1 year, and after 2 years (or at 48 months of age).
What they found
Over two years, the ESDM group showed larger gains than the comparison group in several areas:
- IQ: the ESDM group improved by an average of 17.6 standard score points, compared with 7.0 points in the comparison group.
- Adaptive behavior (everyday skills such as communication, social and daily living skills): the ESDM group kept pace with a typically developing comparison sample, while the community group fell further behind.
- Diagnosis: some children’s diagnosis changed from autistic disorder to the milder category of pervasive developmental disorder, not otherwise specified (PDD-NOS). This happened for 7 children in the ESDM group (30%) and 1 child in the comparison group (5%). PDD-NOS is a category from older diagnostic manuals.
The authors also reported significant gains in language. In practice, families in the ESDM group received about 15 hours per week of therapist time on average, a little less than the 20 hours offered, because of illness, vacations and similar interruptions. Parents reported using the strategies about 16 hours per week.
What this means for families
This is one study, and every child is different. Still, it offers some useful perspective:
- Starting early was studied, and it was linked to gains. The children began intervention before age 2½, and the authors concluded the results underscore the importance of early detection and early intervention.
- Intensity and daily life both seemed to matter. The authors suggest parents’ use of the strategies during daily routines was likely an important ingredient. Play, meals, bath time and diaper changes can all become learning moments.
- Relationship-focused ABA is a recognized approach. The intervention used ABA teaching methods inside warm, affectionate, play-based interactions rather than rigid drills.
- Goals matter more than numbers. Gains in communication, play and everyday skills help a child take part in family life. They are not about making a child “less autistic.” A neurodiversity-affirming approach supports a child’s strengths and helps them build skills, with their comfort and dignity at the center.
If your toddler was recently diagnosed, your pediatrician and your child’s BCBA or care team can talk with you about what level and type of support fits your child and family.
Limitations to keep in mind
- It is a small study. With 48 children, results may not apply to every child or every setting.
- One specific program. The findings are about ESDM as delivered by trained University of Washington clinicians, not about every early intervention.
- The groups weren’t equal in hours or type of service. The comparison group received community services, but at different amounts and types, so the study cannot say which exact ingredient drove the differences.
- Mixed measures. The change in diagnosis was not matched by a significant difference on the ADOS severity scores. The authors noted this is hard to interpret. Repetitive-behavior scores did not change in either group.
- Long-term outcomes were unknown. The authors said that whether the children will keep their gains over time needs follow-up study.
- Disclosure. Two of the authors receive royalties from a book about ESDM.
Group averages also do not predict what will happen for any one child.
How Lucentra Care can help
At Lucentra Care, our BCBA-led team provides in-home ABA therapy for young children and coaches parents to build skills into everyday routines. Families in Howard, Montgomery, Baltimore, Anne Arundel and Prince George’s counties can contact us with questions, or review our insurance coverage guide.
Reference
Dawson G, Rogers S, Munson J, Smith M, Winter J, Greenson J, Donaldson A, Varley J. (2010; published online November 30, 2009). Randomized, controlled trial of an intervention for toddlers with autism: the Early Start Denver Model. Pediatrics, 125(1), e17–e23. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2009-0958 (PubMed: 19948568)
This article summarizes published research for general education and is not medical advice.






